It's the #1 movie on the IMDB.... but is it in The Canon?

I'm gonna make this quick because I'm in New York City dealing with some family business and am in a loud Italian-American home with no actual internet (but with a TV that could double as a speaker for a stadium rock show!). This week's episode of The Canon is about that perennial TNT movie, The Shawshank Redemption. It's #1 on the IMDB - slightly beating The Godfather - which leads Amy and I to wonder if this movie deserves to be in The Canon. After all, can the IMDB voters be wrong?

By the way, at the end of the episode we mention that we're taking a week off because of Sundance. Unfortunately because of this unforeseen trip we're going to actually be missing TWO weeks. Sorry, guys, but we're going to have to wait a little longer to talk about Clerks

In the meantime, swim through this river of shit: